May 2017 – What’s Up?

Here are the top priority notices for May 2017:

Action Alerts

  • Help the Indiana Forest Alliance strategize “how to influence decision-makers to protect state forests from the unprecedented increase in commercial logging.” Details here.
  • Hoosier 2 Hoosier needs volunteers to pick up and process donations from student dorms for resale in August. Last year’s H2H Sale diverted 60 tons from the landfill and raised $45,000 for local charities. Sign up here.

Opportunities

  • Get a free home energy assessment with individualized recommendations for reducing energy use and saving money. Appointment needed and they fill up fast. Call (812) 349-3558 or email to MoCoEnergyChallenge@gmail.com
  • Sierra Club teams up with Arcadia Power. You can get clean renewable energy without changing your electric company or installing solar. Sierra Club members get a $20 credit besides. Details here.

Calls for Help

350.org is looking for a place to store its beautiful parade banners. They are light and pack together compactly, but need a long space (12′) that’s easily accessible. Coalition members are invited to use them when appropriate.

One Good Reason for Optimism

The Solarize Bloomington campaign stopped taking applicants this month after receiving 450 requests. Of these, 223 engaged with the solar installers. A growing number have signed contracts that include a group discount. These home and business owners benefit from the activism of hundreds of Hoosiers that greatly improved SB 309’s harsh terms over time. Though activism could not stop the bill from becoming law, the law will not stop Solarize campaigns from springing up all over the state. We will have details for you in the next issue.

 

People’s Climate March in Indianapolis

Anne Hedin reports:

On April 29, over 20 people in raincoats sorted themselves into carpools in the Marsh parking lot and headed up to Indianapolis for the People’s Climate March Indiana.  This group included TTC members from Citizens Climate Lobby, CSL, SIREN and 350.org as well as the Sycamore Land Trust and other environmentalists.  Others traveled separately from Congregation Beth Shalom and the IU campus, for a total of about 40 people from Bloomington.

Like raindrops flowing into a pond, the Bloomington groups joined with an estimated 450 other marchers gathering inside the Roberts Park United Methodist Church, which hosted the rally because of severe thunderstorms and flood watches.

Meanwhile, up to 375 sister marches were gathering in other cities and about 150,000 people were assembling in front of the White House, according to the People’s Climate movement.

The scene inside the church was colorful and full of good humor. Signs surrounded the altar; banners lined the steps to the balcony. The crowd and the speakers had great and vocal rapport.  A toddler with a pacifier in his mouth rocked out by the altar as Che Jim, Executive Director of Healing Arrows Indigenous Social Justice and Wellness Network, and a fellow Navajo drummer opened the program with a prayer chant. The energy continued to build over the next hours.

The media took pictures of the event pageantry but for coverage of the speeches, you will have to keep reading or turn to the live stream posted by Amanda Shepherd of the Hoosier Environment Council (HEC) on the FB event page.

The keynote speaker was Janet McCabe, who was Assistant Administrator, Office of Air and Radiation, EPA for seven years under Obama. She helped create and roll out the Clean Power Plan. McCabe said that those years proved that we can grow the economy while reducing greenhouse gases and cleaning the air. Some states are already meeting 2022 target levels.  (ICYMI, Indiana is one of the states that joined the lawsuit against the Clean Power Plan led by current EPA administrator, Scott Pruitt.)

McCabe called on the audience to “support our EPA,” pointing out that its first (and fifth) head administrator was a Hoosier, Bill Ruckelshaus. McCabe said, “While I was at the EPA,” McCabe said, “there were thousands of people working there and we all knew you had our backs. We need to educate people, hold the current administration’s EPA officials accountable, and we need to practice what we preach every day.”

She was followed to the stage by Paul Nappier who organizes janitors and security officers with the SEIU (Service Employee International Union) Local 1. In a rousing speech, he made the case that climate change is a labor justice issue, a class issue. “Carrier was actually a big success story for Energize Indiana until the utilities crushed the program and 500 workers lost their jobs, leaving houses shuttered on west side of Indy,” he said. That is the part that doesn’t get into Trump’s story about Carrier. Nappier urged everyone present to protect good solar jobs by signing a solar panel that HEC had brought for that purpose and calling on Gov. Holcomb to veto SB 309. (Sigh.)

Jesse Kharbanda, Executive Director of the Hoosier Environmental Council, spoke to the PCM Indy theme. Indiana is the #CrossroadsOfClimate; it has “epic centrality. The US is one of the world’s largest polluters, the Midwest region is the largest polluter in the US, and Indiana is the largest polluter in the Midwest,” Kharbanda said. He called on Indiana to turn that around by taking a central place in the transition to renewable energy and claiming the good jobs that go with it.

Faryal Kharti, Islamic Society of North America (ISNA) reminded us that every religious tradition teaches us to steward the resources of earth and take no more than our fair share.  Amy Harwell told how an EPA Environmental Justice grant to the Martindale-Brightwood Environmental Justice Collaborative identified the parties responsible for lead pollution made sure it was remediated in her largely African American neighborhood.

A vegan activist, Kurt Schroeder, pointed out that we get to “choose our food and thereby choose our impact on the earth.” The agricultural sector has a huge impact on climate change. A plant-based diet is better for us and for the planet.

Our own Stanley Njuguna (that’s his image on our home page) closed the program with a great burst of energy.  Wrapping up the themes of the day, Njuguna said, “The true power of this movement is a paradigm shift in values. We must make everyday choices in line with our values. We must be relentless in demanding change. Grassroots organizations are the most powerful tools we still have” in resisting destructive policies and supporting each other.

With that, we left the church and marched along the parade route behind banners brought by our newest member, the Bloomington chapter of 350.org. Some bystanders joined our parade. Amazingly, the sun came out while we marched.

Wes Cammenga adds:

On April 29th Reinvest IU marched in solidarity with climate activists around the world — including 200,000 people who showed up at the march in D.C. — at the People’s Climate March in Indianapolis. The day began with a rally in the Robert’s Park Church (this part of the event was moved indoors due to rain) that featured several speakers, including prolific IU student activist Stanley Njuguna. The rally then lead into a march down Meridian St and through Monument Circle.

March for Science in Indianapolis

Dave Simcox reporting

The Saturday April 22 March for Science in Indianapolis was a magnet for me, a biochemist. I also wanted to make sure that marchers saw members of the Indiana Forest Alliance step out for forest science.

The crowd turnout on the west entrance to the Statehouse began building about 10:00 am and by the commencement of speeches at 10:30 we were shoulder-to-shoulder. There had to be in excess of 3000 folks, many holding some creative signs (scientists do that). I located Elizabeth Mahoney, Chair of the IFA Board, who had agreed to carry our banner with me on the march to Earth Day in Military Park and Samantha Buran, an IFA Communication Coordinator. Bloomington was well represented with members of the Citizen’s Climate Lobby and other concerned scientists.

Linda Miller, IFA Member, Elizabeth Mahoney, IFA Board Chair, and Dave Simcox, IFA Board Member

The speeches were excellent and arousing. While I cannot remember them all, Jesse Kharbanda, Executive Director of the Hoosier Environmental Council, gave a fiery speech about current political disdain for science and the lack of facts surrounding SB 309, the solar bill. Jason Rylander, Sr. Staff Attorney for Defenders of Wildlife, pointed out grave concerns for the Monarch Butterfly and the Red Knot’s dependency on horseshoe crabs which are declining on the Eastern Flyway.

I need to give a big shout out to Dr. Rae Schnapps, Conservation Director of IFA. The crowd was quickly engaged when they saw how passionate she is for defending the forest, both as an ecosystem and against clear-cut logging. Readers here should check out the book, “The Hidden Life of Trees” which speaks to integrated forest life. Dead trees, whether standing or decaying on the forest floor, have a role to play is sustaining this valuable ecosystem. Our “Conserve Our State Forests” sign was appreciated by the crowd.

The March was capped off as the throngs wound their way to the Earth Day event with hundreds of booths and typical fare. It is great to see Hoosiers speak out by showing up and demonstrating their support for one of the great strengths of America, our science and engineering educational system and capabilities. One thing I learned as a business manager, you play to your strengths to compete. Unfortunately, our current leaders do not want to acknowledge nor invest in America’s amazing competitive advantage in which I and so many more take great pride.

Lana Eisenberg adds

What was exciting was how many people turned out to show their support. The IDS reported an estimated 10,000 people marched in Indianapolis. On our way back from Military Park (the end of the march) to the garage, my husband and I looked back along the route and saw six blocks of marchers that still had not reached the park.

We were part of the group from Citizens Climate Lobby, and I also saw people I know from IU and Congregation Beth Shalom among the marchers. It was a very heartening experience to see so many people marching with home-made signs and good cheer. It makes you confident in your fellow man.

Sierra Club Teams Up with Arcadia Power

Many times this spring, as SB 309 made its way from Senate Utilities Committee to the House floor and onto Governor Holcomb’s desk, I received email ads from Arcadia Power, as you may have. They explicitly targeted Hoosiers whose options for renewable energy would be diminished by SB 309. “Forget waiting for legislation,” one said, “ensure that every time you pay your power bill with your local utility, it supports renewable energy projects.”

The one that came on Earth Day, under a Daily Kos logo, said, “Over 8,000 pounds of coal. That is what it takes to power the average home in America for just one year. Your home. With Earth Day this weekend, it has never been a more important time to come together and send a message that we are going to make a clean energy future happen ourselves, despite the Trump Administration’s attempts to bring us back to the dark coal age.”

One came last week, on the very day Gov. Holcomb signed SB 309. This one came under a familiar logo:

We all know what the Sierra Club is but what is Arcadia Power and why is Sierra Club putting its trusted brand on an ad for Arcadia? When I googled it, I was surprised to find a press release from Sierra Club dating back to October of 2015. In it, Sierra Club explains that they are partners because “Arcadia Power offers the first nationwide community wind program. The company provides an alternative for the 85% of Americans in all 50 states who pay a utility bill but don’t have the ability to install rooftop solar, don’t own their homes, or who live in apartments.”

Through a network of wind farms, Arcadia lines up a supply of renewable energy, gets it certified for renewable energy credits (RECs), and exchanges those credits with utility companies for payments that go back to the producers and to Arcadia as the broker and account manager. The utilities apply those credits to the account of customers who request renewable energy that the utility is not producing itself. This complicated string of transactions is like “making a market” on the stock exchange.

Lots of people got Arcadia ads this spring. Because the company and the concept are relatively unknown, somebody asked about it on our neighborhood association discussion list, with a touch of skepticism. I borrow this excellent answer from my neighbor Sarah Portwood, with her permission. She writes:

“Here’s a great little primer on companies like Arcadia Power: http://grist.org/climate-energy/are-renewable-energy-certificates-a-scam/

“Here’s the gist: If you sign up with Arcadia, you will start paying Arcadia instead of Duke for your electricity each month. Arcadia will pay Duke for you. Depending on what Arcadia plan you sign up for (and what plan(s) are available to you), you might see zero increase in your monthly bill, or you might see a small per-kilowatt increase in your monthly bill (such as for a premium plan). In exchange, Arcadia will offset your home’s electricity use with green, renewable resources (e.g. wind). For a free (no fees) plan, Arcadia typically sources 50% of your electricity from wind. For a premium plan, 100% of your electricity use would be offset with wind power for a per-kilowatt charge added to your bill. Now, of course you’ll still be using the same electricity that you always have, being pulled from the same grid. The difference is that you will be purchasing what’s known as “Renewable Energy Certificates” (RECs) to prove that you are using renewable energy and that there is a demand for it here in Bloomington. Theoretically this helps keep green energy prices competitive and helps green energy producers know where their consumer base is.”

And if you are wondering how you can be sure that all this is really happening, “Customers also get access to a personalized online and mobile dashboard for their energy usage and renewable power purchase that features advanced analytics, rewards, and energy-efficiency opportunities,” according to the Sierra Club press release.

As of today, May 10, the Arcadia Power website has a sign out: “Welcome Sierra Club supporters! Sign up for clean energy today and $20 will be applied to your account!”

–Anne Hedin